Notting Hill Carnival
Labroke Grove is the heart of the spectacular Notting Hill Carnival,
held each August Bank Holiday since 1966. This holiday always
falls on the last weekend of August with Sunday and Monday being
the major carnival days. The festivities started as a local
affair set up by the West Indian immigrants of the area and
has become a full-blooded Caribbean carnival, attracting millions
of people from all around the world. There are scores of massive
'sound systems', many spectacular floats and steel drum bands
additionally, to keep you well fed, there are hundreds of stalls
lining the streets of the area selling all sorts of food and
drink including Caribbean specialities
GLA Carnival Review Group Under
Attack 3/11/00
Ken Livingstones GLA Carnival Review Group came under attack
last Thursday, 26th October, at the Carnival Residents Association
Annual General Meeting. The GLA Review Panel, which was created
in a move to address residential problems with relation to the
Notting Hill Carnival, has been criticized by community organizations
and local authorities for failing to provide any local representation
on its board. The GLA Review also chose to hold their independent
review meeting on the 26th October, a move seen as being in
direct conflict to the interests of local residential groups.The
AGM, chaired by Cy Ford, Chairman of the Carnival Residents
Group, opened with apologies from local MP Karen Buck, Clare
Holder, Chief Executive of the Carnival Committee and Lee
Jasper, the chair of the Carnival Review Panel. Angela Bray,
the Local Assembly Member for Notting Hill, did attend on behalf
of the Review Panel, in what she stated was a move to ensure
that residential concerns were heard and received. Ms Bray backed
local concern with regard to the Review Panel, I am also uncomfortable
about the way in which the group was set up there should certainly
be representation from local authorities and resident groups.
She highlighted issues such as noise, location, duration, size
and safety as important areas in need of negotiation and asked
local residents to voice their concerns, opinions and ideas
so that they could be relayed back to the Review Panel. A major
problem expressed by local residential groups is the lack of
response to local voices and opinions. Cy Ford stated at the
Post Carnival Meeting earlier this month: We come here every
year, we voice the same concerns every year, yet nothing ever
happens. Residents feel that there is no firm body that appears
to have absolute influence over the Carnival, with all organizations
involved shrugging off responsibilities when complaints or concerns
are expressed. Martin Kingsford, Chief Executive of TMO, stated,
The key to all discussions is accountability Who is in charge
of the Carnival? Residents should know; they should have rights.
The creation of the Carnival Review has not provided any answers
to these questions, residents still feel that they do not have
a voice with respect to the Carnival, There is no
recognition of residents in this discussion. Mr Kingsford suggested
that an interagency carnival plan should be developed, with
open text accountability, People should have faith in these
agencies, there should be a chain of command set out in black
and white. Attendees of the meeting were both angry and desperate
with the issues at hand, they want changes to take place with
regard to the organization of the carnival, a majority want
the presence of sound systems readdressed believing that they
are often the root to many problems of noise, safety and crowd
control. Mr Hugh Berger stated: There should be no amplification
of music at all whether that be stationary or mobile, the type
of music is the problem - aggressive hip hop breeds violence,
danger and aggression. However, sound systems have come to represent
a large element of the Carnival providing not merely aggressive,
violent hip hop (Mr Bergers definition), but also
reggae, dance and R&B. The carnival was originally created
to promote unity between black and white people in the 1950s
and this may be recognized today in the diversity of music and
the people who collect to appreciate it. Organization of the
event does need to be addressed, with this years carnival
presenting many problems with regard to crowd crushes, late
unlicensed noise, the devastating deaths of two men and the
violent attack and rape of one woman. These are major issues
that are at the forefront residents minds, issues that make
them uneasy about the event and about living in the area over
the August bank holiday, but issues that they believe are not
being addressed with respect to the local people. The Carnival
Review Panel is due to circulate questionnaires throughout the
borough, in an attempt to acquire feedback from local residents
in respect of the carnival. It may be described by the panel
as a first move to address issues, but residents have been voicing
their concerns for many years and cannot be expected to have
faith in what can be seen as such a detached and unrepresentative
body.
Post Carnival 2000 Review 13/10/00
As the yearly post-carnival meeting took place last Wednesday,
local Notting Hill residents voiced their anger over the continual
dismissal of their issues and grievances. The meeting, at Isaac
Newton Centre in Lancaster Road, Notting Hill, was attended
by the largest turnout ever, including the Carnival Residents
Group, who were present to discuss issues relating to safety,
policing and location of the August Bank Holiday carnival. With
the death of two festival-goers, Carnival 2000 presented this
years review with many poignant thoughts with regard to overcrowding,
violence and organisation. The carnival always appears to have
been a double edged knife for locals, whilst being the location
to one of the most unique events of its kind, where cultural
diversity can be experienced in its most vivid form, the event
simultaneously presents many problems to residents located within
the vicinity. The meeting was established for residents to voice
their opinions on the impact of the carnival weekend on the
local community. Mr Cy Ford, the Chairman of Carnival Residents
Group, stated that this years Carnival was the largest ever,
with the concentration of people causing many problems. Major
problems for residents concerned facilities, such as toilets,
noise created by sound systems, and the rise in crime. The 'softly
softly' approach to policing the event this year has been firmly
criticised in the light of the two highly publicised murders.
Whilst another event dealt a blow to the image of the carnival
yesterday, when it was released by police that a young woman
had been attacked and viscously raped on 27th August during
the carnival festivities. Detectives kept the investigation
of the rape a secret for more than a month for "operational
reasons". Police today insisted they had not deliberately
covered up the incident. With at least 2 million people in attendance
this year, Mr Ford was firm to stress that unless something
was done to ease the stress on the neighbourhood a major catastrophe
could be expected. He was also quick to highlight the opinion
that the residents concerns were not being addressed, "Every
year we come here, we tell everyone sitting there what we do
not agree with. Every year nothing is done, we will be back
here next year talking about the same things." Residents
feel that they and their issues are brushed aside with regard
to the carnival and their frustration couldn't have been illustrated
more vividly at the meeting on Wednesday night. Clare Holder,
Carnival Trust chief executive, stressed that the meeting was
a vocal affair, within which the residents were encouraged to
put forward their opinions. She stated that the trust needed
to hear about the impact inflicted on the residents throughout
the carnival weekend, in order to make changes, however stressed
that improvements have been made year after year. The main issue
addressed, was crowd management/flow on the carnival route and
problem spots where capacity reached saturation point. "Issues
need to be discussed with the necessary bodies, such as the
local authorities, Greater London Council and the police",
Ms Holder stated "a reroute may be the only solution"
With regard to an increase in crime, and more specifically the
murders of Greg Watson and Abdul Bhatti, Ms Holder said: "It
is a sad and regrettable matter, but most of all a waste of
valuable lives" An Annual General Meeting is due to be
held on Thursday 26th October at 6.30pm, at 'The Small Hall',
Kensington Town Hall, Hornton St W8.
Notting Hill Carnival 2000
The Notting Hill Carnival is Europe's largest festival and this
year's event attracted up to one million and a half people.
The 36th annual Carnival featured more than 75 costume bands
and two live stages. For the great majority of visitors, Carnival
2000 was an enjoyable experience. Thunder storms briefly blew
in on both days. These may have kept the numbers down compared
to last year's record attendance but a little rain was not going
to stop those who did come enjoying themselves. While most of
the organised sound systems shut down at 7pm last night as scheduled,
with the majority of the motorised floats turning their music
off two hours later, tens of thousands of people were still
out towards midnight at impromptu street parties, refusing to
accept that Carnival - and summer with it - was finally over.
Dozens of private parties in flats and houses across the carnival
area also prolonged the festivities into this morning. "There
were floats still coming down Ladbroke Grove at 12.30 at night,
when it should have finished at 9.00," said Kensington
and Chelsea councillor David Campion. "We will be working
with the Carnival organisers to see if we can contain it within
the area and finish it on time." The coveted first place
at the Panorama steel band competition which takes place on
the Saturday before Carnival was won for the first time by The
Mangrove Band. For the past nine years the steel band competition
has been won by Ebony, pipping Mangrove into second place. There
were two fatalities at Carnival, a man was stabbed to death
by an unknown assailant in Kensal Road shortly after 2000 on
Monday, a Police spokeswoman said. He had been taken by ambulance
to St Mary's Hospital, Paddington, where he was declared dead.
The second murder also took place on Monday evening. Abdul Bhatti,
28, a salesman from Hounslow, west London, was attacked by robbers
and died in hospital on Tuesday night. Its the first fatalities
since 1997. Deputy Assistant Commissioner Tarique Ghaffur said:
"Well over one and a half million people have attended
the carnival this year, which has been a happy occasion for
the vast majority of people. "However, this year's celebration
has been marred by a number of isolated incidents, most notably
the attack on a young man whose death is being treated as murder."
Prior to the fatal stabbing, police had recorded 89 arrests
at the two-day event, most of them for public order and drugs
offences. Officers said two people were injured when they fell
into the basement of a house after its railings collapsed during
a crowd crush. Both were treated by the ambulance service at
the scene and one was said to be "quite seriously injured".
Another man was said to be "very seriously injured"
with internal damage after apparently being attacked at about
1930 at the junction of Westbourne Grove and Kensington Park
Road. Police also said one man had been stabbed and another
had been glassed in the face. The main celebrations ended at
1900, the cut-off point agreed between police and organisers.
All sound systems were due to shut down and the floats disperse,
although police conceded that many private parties continued
into the night. A massive operation is under way to clear away
the debris left by people at the carnival. The Police are urging
Ken Livingstone and carnival organisers to reduce the size of
the Notting Hill Carnival. The assistant police commissioner
Ian Johnston, said "We don't want to see the carnival stopped
altogether but finishing it earlier could be considered, as
many crimes do tend to happen in the hours of darkness."
The murders were the first deaths since 1997. An urgent review
of the beleaguered Notting Hill Carnival is to be launched,
with plans to extend the route into Brent. Brent council is
keen to be involved in the carnival on condition that residents
approve and its own safety requirements are met. The strategy
rethink follows the revelation that the Metropolitan Police
was told to take a "softly, softly" approach to carnival
crime for fear of sparking "violent disorder". This
year's street party was marred by two murders and 19 stabbings.
The plan includes an extended route into Harrow Road, Brent,
and Notting Hill Gate to minimise crushes; "comfort zones"
to seat up to 30,000 spectators and to prevent revellers crossing
the route; and 500 stewards - 300 more than this year - to control
crowds. The trust's chief executive Claire Holder said: "While
we have every sympathy with the families of those killed and
deplore violence, the carnival should not be stopped as it is
part of culture and tradition. Even if we stopped organising
it people would still turn up. "The answer is crowd management
and the only way we can do that is with more stewards and a
bigger route stretching into Harrow Road in Brent, giving people
more room to manoeuvre. What has happened to Carnival is exactly
what has happened to the M25 - we need extra lanes. We are reviewing
our strategy, as we do each year, but with more urgency this
time. Crowd management will feature heavily in the review. We
want to make sure everything is workable." Ms Holder added:
"The hysteria after this year's event does not help focus
the mind on the real issues. The event has not grown out of
control. The two stabbings and 267 arrests should be put into
context. Carnival is still a happy affair - and the behaviour
of a minority we cannot account for." Her views were backed
by Assistant Commissioner Ian Johnston, who said the event should
be spread out over a larger area of London and should finish
before nightfall. The suggestions for a safer carnival will
be aired at a residential meeting at the end of the month, which
will also discuss the existing eight safety zones - quiet areas
into which the police direct crowds during crushes - as well
as plans for bands in Chepstow Road to help the flow of traffic
from Ladbroke Grove.
|